Red Dead Redemption 2 Review Thread 97 Meta (90 Reviews) 97 Open (93 Reviews)

[BananaKing]

I think everyone would try dispute at least one of those scores, such is the nature of metacritic and review aggregation.

I doubt many would agree with the 93 of MSG5 though. Even die hard fans say it's a disappointment.

The Xbox version of RDR2 is sitting on a 99 meta from 18 reviews.

[Xevross]

I doubt many would agree with the 93 of MSG5 though. Even die hard fans say it's a disappointment.

The Xbox version of RDR2 is sitting on a 99 meta from 18 reviews.

Well this is probably true.

Yeah, if it can hold that then that would obviously be incredible. But of course the only reason its at 99 is because the harsher reviews haven't been posted under xb1, and not due to x power like so many on era are jumping to praise

[Xevross]

Since it first went up at 96 with 37 reviews its just gone up and up, and is now one of the highest 97s of all time on meta. 98 is actually possible!

[Xevross]

Opencritic up to 98

[BananaKing]

fudgy hell! I just counted and it has 40 perfect scores on meta already. 40 "10's". I hope it at least stays at 97...

^^I wonder if edge comes in with another 10 if it jumps up to 98. That would be insane. Since if I remem correctly edge has a high weighting.

[Xevross]

fudgy hell! I just counted and it has 40 perfect scores on meta already. 40 "10's". I hope it at least stays at 97...

^^I wonder if edge comes in with another 10 if it jumps up to 98. That would be insane. Since if I remem correctly edge has a high weighting.

Yes I think an Edge 10 would bump it to 98 right now. Needs to keep up this average until then though...

[BananaKing]

Yes I think an Edge 10 would bump it to 98 right now. Needs to keep up this average until then though...

BELIEVE!

BELIEVE!

Legend wake the fudge up and start posting you lazy dog

[Legend]

Wowza they did it!!!

I doubt many would agree with the 93 of MSG5 though. Even die hard fans say it's a disappointment.

The Xbox version of RDR2 is sitting on a 99 meta from 18 reviews.

I loved mgsv. Even with flaws it deserves a 93.

BELIEVE!

BELIEVE!

Legend wake the fudge up and start posting you lazy dog

It's 8 am, I'm up!

[BananaKing]

Wowza they did it!!!I loved mgsv. Even with flaws it deserves a 93.
It's 8 am, I'm up!

I tell you to get up and this is how you repay me? By telling me I'm wrong?!

[the-pi-guy]

Hopefully it stays at 97.  I'd be mad at Xev if it went to 98.  

[Legend]

I tell you to get up and this is how you repay me? By telling me I'm wrong?!

Well the simple fix is for you to not say wrong things in the first place.  

Hopefully it stays at 97.  I'd be mad at Xev if it went to 98.  

So many of us are at risk of losing points from it being outside our range.

[Xevross]

Hopefully it stays at 97.  I'd be mad at Xev if it went to 98.  

Lol well I don't think there's much of a chance of 98 so don't worry  

[BananaKing]

Hopefully it stays at 97.  I'd be mad at Xev if it went to 98.  

No. Hopefully it raises to 98.

Well the simple fix is for you to not say wrong things in the first place.  

So many of us are at risk of losing points from it being outside our range.

What I said was 100% correct!

[Dr. Pezus]

Holy shame

[Xevross]

Hopefully it falls to 96  

Holy shame

Indeed, I personally thought 97 would be unlikely given the reviews this gen, but I guess reviewers still have a massive hard-on for R* even if they're giving other games lower scores