The GOTY 2015 into the Media

[ethomaz]

really?

TW3 massacres bloodborne. i have no bias what so ever to either game. first time playing a souls type game, and first time playing a Witcher game. ( i actually tried both demons souls and TW2 for like 15 minutes each, but it doesnt really count). and TW3 is just a superior product. its story is deep, its side quests are amazing, its world is fantastic, its characters are interesting, and its enemies and combat are fun and challenging. of course, you can say a lot of those apply to BB as well, and that is true. but BB just cant match the sheer scale of TW3, which just has a lot more to offer.

bloodborne is a very good game, TW3 however is just one of those games that provide an amazing experience, it doesnt get everything right of course, but it reaches that point where it provides an experience that is truly memorable and magical.

About your points...

Story: BB has a way deeper story than TW3... you can say TW3 has more but BB lore is unmatched... and yes I'm even comparing to the book's story that is better than the game itself.
Side quest: Yeap TW3 has more useless side-quest to waste time.
World: BB world is so fudge amazing... TW3 world is like others games.
Character: I found BB main character way more interesting than Gerard... in fact even in the books Gerard is a weak and boring character... the others character that he interacts are good to sustain and create a good story.
Enemies: I don't need even explain BB enemies are more challenges and interesting... the bosses are so great and different each other.
Combat: Are you kidding? TW3 is terrible... no variation, no skill... it is so basic... it not even in the same league than Bloodborne combat system.

So only one points is true at all... of course you can disagree with all of them except Combat that is really weak in TW3.

If Sony do another DLC to Bloodborne I will play it again and and again... in fact I have a more memorable and magical experience with Old Hunter DLC than TW3.

No Ori either, guess MS' biggest lineup in gaming history simply stands above the idea of getting awards, all it needs is MS' approval.

(But seriously, are we sure this isn't a readers choice list?)

The TOP10 reader choices:

1. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
2. Bloodborne
3. Fallout 4
4. Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain
5. Life is Strange
6. Splatoon
7. Rocket League
8. Xenoblade Chronicles X
9. Batman Arkham Knight
10. Super Mario Maker

You can see the difference

[Legend]

Haha people upset bloodborne won.

[BananaKing]

About your points...

Story: BB has a way deeper story than TW3... you can say TW3 has more but BB lore is unmatched... and yes I'm even comparing to the book's story that is better than the game itself.
Side quest: Yeap TW3 has more useless side-quest to waste time.
World: BB world is so fudge amazing... TW3 world is like others games.
Character: I found BB main character way more interesting than Gerard... in fact even in the books Gerard is a weak and boring character... the others character that he interacts are good to sustain and create a good story.
Enemies: I don't need even explain BB enemies are more challenges and interesting... the bosses are so great and different each other.
Combat: Are you kidding? TW3 is terrible... no variation, no skill... it is so basic... it not even in the same league than Bloodborne combat system.

So only one points is true at all... of course you can disagree with all of them except Combat that is really weak in TW3.

If Sony do another DLC to Bloodborne I will play it again and and again... in fact I have a more memorable and magical experience with Old Hunter DLC than TW3.

what? BB has a better and deeper story than The Witcher 3? not in a million years. The Witchers 3's story includes all sorts of subjects such as politics, love, war, family, loyalty, morals, racism and ethics. it tops it off by a very strong dialogue branches that let you project yourself into the main character. its dialogue branches are also not a clear "good and bad" choice, each action has its own consequence.  Actually, some SIDE QUESTS (useles? seriously?) have a better story than bloodbornes entire story.

id disagree saying that TW3 gameplay is terrible. BB has better combat id agree. but TW3's combat is pretty fun as well.

Bloodbrone has a more stylized world. but TW3 has a living breathing world with, one where you feel you are truly a part of it. not just some levels filled with beasts and enemies.

TW3 also has villains, not just enemies. they have their own characters and motives. for example a werewolf is just a beast in bloodborne, in the witcher 3 a they show you the other side of a warewolf, the human side.

Bloodbornes main character more interesting that Geralt?(i seriously doubt you played through TW3 if you think his name is gerard) Bloodbornes main character is not a character. just an avatar. he is a speechless character. that just fights. he has no intentions, emotions, motives, desires or anything resembling a character for that matter. he literally does nothing other than fight. exactly how is BB's avatar a better character than geralt?

[Rorono]

Gameplay BB > W3
Art direction BB > W3
Technical graphics W3 > BB
Sound BB > W3
Story W3 > BB

[Legend]

Gameplay BB > W3
Art direction BB > W3
Technical graphics W3 > BB
Sound BB > W3
Story W3 > BB

Card Game W3 > BB

[Rorono]

fist bumping big monsters is a better mini game though

[Dr. Pezus]

Card Game W3 > BB

Beauty of npc's W3>>>>BB

bosom W3>>>BB

[the-pi-guy]

Beauty of npc's W3>>>>BB

bosom W3>>>BB

Creepy Doll  BB >>>>>>W3
Creepy game BB>>>W3

[ethomaz]

It is because the name in the Brasilian translacional is Gerald lol

And yes I do think BB wins in all my points... BB main character (avatar) is so cool and he interact with everything is amazing (btw Gorgon Freeman is a speckless char in Half-Life and one of the best created in a video game).

The world in BB >>>>> TW3 world.

And the story in TW3 is not that impressive... BB story is something amazing.

[Dr. Pezus]

It is because the name in the Brasilian translacional is Gerald lol

And yes I do think BB wins in all my points... BB main character (avatar) is so cool and he interact with everything is amazing (btw Gorgon Freeman is a speckless char in Half-Life and one of the best created in a video game).

The world in BB >>>>> TW3 world.

And the story in TW3 is not that impressive... BB story is something amazing.

I think this can all be explained by a bad Brazilian translation

[ethomaz]

Edge GOTY is Bloodborne.

The true 2015 king was reveled.

BTW they nailed the top 5.

5. Kerbal Space Program
4. Her Story
3. Spaltoon
2. Metal Gear Solid V
1. Bloodborne

[ethomaz]

Something I foundry interestinng was that Big outlet até choosing BB while small ones TW3.

[Legend]

Something I foundry interestinng was that Big outlet até choosing BB while small ones TW3.

Have a handy list of which sites chose which game?

[ethomaz]

Have a handy list of which sites chose which game?

I will make a list when I get home tomorrow.

[Dr. Pezus]

Edge GOTY is Bloodborne.

The true 2015 king was reveled.

BTW they nailed the top 5.

5. Kerbal Space Program
4. Her Story
3. Spaltoon
2. Metal Gear Solid V
1. Bloodborne

Keep trying lulz. It's like 200 vs 25 I guess