Forum's Favorite Game: pre-Round 1+Round 1

[the-pi-guy]

You are a mod, so feel free to sticky whatever you want.

I didn't want to abuse my powers.  

[Cute Pikachu]

1 Sky rim
-1 Shadow of Mordor
1 Mario Galaxy
1 Viva Pinata
1 Viva Pinata Trouble in Paradise
1 Halo 3
-1 Final Fantasy 13
1 Tales of Zestria
.5 Dragon Quest Heroes
-1 Link to the Past

[the-pi-guy]

1 Sky rim
-1 Shadow of Mordor
1 Mario Galaxy
1 Viva Pinata
1 Viva Pinata Trouble in Paradise
1 Halo 3
-1 Final Fantasy 13
1 Tales of Zestria
.5 Dragon Quest Heroes
-1 Link to the Past

Those games weren't nominated.  

[Cute Pikachu]

Those games weren't nominated.  

Phhft I don't follow rules  

[the-pi-guy]

Phhft I don't follow rules  

Just quote the OP, it's up in the top spoilers.  
Then go through and give everything a score.
If you can only give the first 10 a rating, feel free to come back later.  

[Dr. Pezus]

1 The Last of Us
0.5 Final Fantasy X
1 Uncharted 2
0.5 Super Mario RPG
1 Age of Empires II
1 Grand Theft Auto V
0.5 Mario Kart Wii
0.5 Pokemon Diamond
1 San Andreas
1 Super Mario Galaxy
1 God Of War 3
1 Heavy Rain
1 FEZ
1 Metal Gear Solid V
1 Mass Effect 2
0.5 Super Mario World
0.5 Final Fantasy VI
0.5 Final Fantasy VII
0.5 Devil May Cry 3
1 Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
1 Braid
1 Flower
? Riven
1 Rocket league
1 rachet and clank: CiT
1 Half-Life 2
1 Batman: Arkham City
1 Witcher 3
1 Gran Turismo
1 Bloodborne
0.5 Ocarina of Time
-0.5 Metroid Prime
0.5 Majora's Mask
0.5 Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
1 Chrono Trigger
1 Killzone 2
1 Vice City
1 God of War 2
1 Red Dead Redemption
1 Super Mario 64
1 ICO
1 Shadow of the colossus
-0.5 Atelier Rorona Plus
1 Final Fantasy IX
? Lunar Silver star story  
0.5 LOZ Ocarina of Time
? Tex Murphy pandora directive
? Astro Warrior

[Dr. Pezus]

BTW, ocarina of time is mentioned twice

[Legend]

BTW, ocarina of time is mentioned twice

Impressive observation skills!

[the-pi-guy]

BTW, ocarina of time is mentioned twice

Here are 4 possible responses I have.

-Nah, one of them is different.
-It must be destined to become the GOTF (game of the forum)
-One is the 3DS version or something.....
-Ahhh you caught me!

[Mmm_fish_tacos]

dang it, this is lunar.

[the-pi-guy]

*2 weeks later*

[Legend]

*2 weeks later*

Time flies when it's cold outside!