Red Dead Redemption 2 Review Thread 97 Meta (90 Reviews) 97 Open (93 Reviews)

[TobyDuf]

With just D-Bal added there is a chance it makes 98, any other perfect scores and it looks quite likely. All it takes is one or two lower scores to kill any chance of 98 though.

Definitely rooting for 98 score to happen, but I'm skeptical. I have an impression that the reviews that come later on are usually a bit lower than the ones that are posted early. Maybe I'm wrong.

[the-pi-guy]

Definitely rooting for 98 score to happen, but I'm skeptical. I have an impression that the reviews that come later on are usually a bit lower than the ones that are posted early. Maybe I'm wrong.

Yeah, that's usually what happens.  
A couple games have gone up with more reviews though, like Astrobot.  

[Xevross]

Definitely rooting for 98 score to happen, but I'm skeptical. I have an impression that the reviews that come later on are usually a bit lower than the ones that are posted early. Maybe I'm wrong.

It often happens thanks to reviewers who are more harsh just deciding to pick up the game themselves later on. It seems like this game has dodged most lower scoring reviewers though. Riot Pixels is the only main one left that I can think of and they don't do that many reviews.

[Xevross]

Haven't updated this in a while, but the above mentioned Riot Pixels did decide to drop a review. They scored it 9/10, which is super high for them. A 100 and two 96s were also added to meta, which reduces the average slightly.

[Legend]

Good enough to call it for our predictions?

[Xevross]

Good enough to call it for our predictions?

Its still so close to 98, I think we should wait until Edge is added just to make sure.

[BananaKing]

Its still so close to 98, I think we should wait until Edge is added just to make sure.

Edge isn't added yet? It's till right behind the galaxy games so it might jump to 98

[Xevross]

Edge isn't added yet? It's till right behind the galaxy games so it might jump to 98

Edge gets added once meta gets their hands on it themselves. Should be tomorrow judging by last few months of Edge reviews on meta.

[Kerotan]

Edge added

[Xevross]

Edge added

dang, it didn't even move places, still behind the SMGs. Okay, guess its fair to call it now!

[Kerotan]

dang, it didn't even move places, still behind the SMGs. Okay, guess its fair to call it now!

How many more reviews on ps4 should this get over say the next month?

[Xevross]

How many more reviews on ps4 should this get over say the next month?

Hard to say, I think its pretty much got all the reviews it will ever get. It certainly won't get enough to change from a 97 at this point.

Anyway I'm sure its not too hard for Legend to update the scores if it does change down the line.

[Kerotan]

Hard to say, I think its pretty much got all the reviews it will ever get. It certainly won't get enough to change from a 97 at this point.

Anyway I'm sure its not too hard for Legend to update the scores if it does change down the line.

TLOU 98,
GOD of War 118,
RDR2 91,
Zelda 109,
Horizon 115,
Mario Odyssey 113,
Uncharted 4 113,
Spiderman 111,
Destiny ps4 95,
Destiny 2 ps4 95,
Monster Hunter world ps4 93,

So what I'm thinking is it will make it over 100 reviews. That's still 9 more to go and that could potentially move it to 98 although a long shot because you just need 1 or 2 lower ones to ensure it stays 97.

[Xevross]

TLOU 98,
GOD of War 118,
RDR2 91,
Zelda 109,
Horizon 115,
Mario Odyssey 113,
Uncharted 4 113,
Spiderman 111,
Destiny ps4 95,
Destiny 2 ps4 95,
Monster Hunter world ps4 93,

So what I'm thinking is it will make it over 100 reviews. That's still 9 more to go and that could potentially move it to 98 although a long shot because you just need 1 or 2 lower ones to ensure it stays 97.

+32 for the xbox one version, +24 if you ignore the 'xbox' reviewers. So the total is 115/ 123. Its done.

[Kerotan]

+32 for the xbox one version, +24 if you ignore the 'xbox' reviewers. So the total is 115/ 123. Its done.

So no more reviews? I think it gets a few more