HollowKnight Silksong |OT| 530k on Steam

Started by the-pi-guy, Aug 21, 2025, 02:41 PM

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

the-pi-guy

My 1 hour impressions, are that I liked the first one a little more. So I'm really not far with it.  

I'd say a pretty big upgrade in visuals. It feels more vibrant and lively.  

I wouldn't even call these spoilers per se, but I'm going to tag them anyway.  
Spoiler for Hidden:
The first game has a main base, that you can usually reliably get back to.<br><br>So far, the sequel feels more obtuse map wise. The levels are much more complex, and maps of the levels are harder to get.&nbsp;<br><br>

Legend

What a downgrade! Trash, dumpster fire.
VizionEck Cube Royale is releasing this year
 
"I'm Miranda Armbrust" -Me

BananaKing


Legend

Quote from: BananaKing on Sep 08, 2025, 05:39 AMWhy do you say that?
I was just responding to Pi. I haven't played either game.
VizionEck Cube Royale is releasing this year
 
"I'm Miranda Armbrust" -Me

the-pi-guy

I have been liking it more as I go.  

I saw r/DarkSouls2 compare Silksong as the Dark Souls 2 of Hollow Knight, and based on how people talk about it, I kind of don't think it's too bad of a comparison.

Quote

I'm not sure that I've seen any long runbacks in Silksong though. 

But a lot of people are definitely complaining about the difficulty. 

Legend

You've been talking about a lot of issues with Dark Souls 2, so I have no idea how bad it actually is.

Hollowknight 1 a 10, Hollowknight 2 an 8? Or is Hollowknight 2 still a 10ish, it's just that the previous was so great?
VizionEck Cube Royale is releasing this year
 
"I'm Miranda Armbrust" -Me

the-pi-guy

Quote from: Legend on Sep 08, 2025, 09:33 PMOr is Hollowknight 2 still a 10ish, it's just that the previous was so great?
It's more so this in my book.  

I had a real good time with the first game just a few months ago.  


Reviewers are loving Silksong much more though.  

Opencritic

Legend

Quote from: the-Pi-guy on Sep 08, 2025, 09:47 PMIt's more so this in my book. 

I had a real good time with the first game just a few months ago. 


Reviewers are loving Silksong much more though. 

Opencritic
I don't trust reviewers. They have horrible accuracy, doubly so with a hyped game. But it's great you still consider it great.
VizionEck Cube Royale is releasing this year
 
"I'm Miranda Armbrust" -Me

the-pi-guy

Quote from: Legend on Sep 08, 2025, 10:32 PMI don't trust reviewers. They have horrible accuracy, doubly so with a hyped game. But it's great you still consider it great.
I trust reviewers. I am certain that those 10 people had a 10/10 experience. That doesn't mean anyone else will.  

Legend

Quote from: the-Pi-guy on Sep 09, 2025, 01:58 AMI trust reviewers. I am certain that those 10 people had a 10/10 experience. That doesn't mean anyone else will. 
Yeah it's not that any specific reviewer is bad, it's the aggregate of metacritic/opencritic that is bad.


Steam tends to be better imo. 94% of hollowknight reviews in the last 30 days are positive. 91% of silksong are positive. So both incredible games, but it seems others agree with you that the first is the more incredible game.
VizionEck Cube Royale is releasing this year
 
"I'm Miranda Armbrust" -Me

the-pi-guy

Currently sitting at 94 on OC, 93 on MC

I kind of expect it'll continue to go down just a little.  

Legend

Quote from: the-Pi-guy on Sep 09, 2025, 08:39 PMCurrently sitting at 94 on OC, 93 on MC

I kind of expect it'll continue to go down just a little. 
No it has to stay exactly where it is!
VizionEck Cube Royale is releasing this year
 
"I'm Miranda Armbrust" -Me

darkknightkryta

My student's have been playing Silksong.  It looks good.