Started by ethomaz, May 12, 2016, 03:15 PM
previous topic - next topic0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Ditto. Shooting the Dr.s was amazing.That the difference of TLOU... I was so linked to Ellie that I didn't need to think twice... she was my daughter and I will do everything to save her.
Ditto. Shooting the Dr.s was amazing.Don't shoot the Drs!
Wayyyy too generousYou do know elaborating is much more effective than ad nauseum
TLoU ending was fine. But it was no where near a closed ending and ended abruptly. Just like the order. TLoU didn't have fast paced gameplay on hard or above. Or else you'd run out of ammo and supplies and die. TLoU was just as linearIt did not end abruptly. What do you want them to do?
I will make a dumb comparison but that is what I feel about...Well shame, if you liked the matrix that says a lot
TLOU ending has the same impact for me than Matrix ending... it was perfect, enough, a ending that make you thing about.
Matrix had sequels for reasons but the first one continue to be the complete package for me... it is amazing.
Same for TLOU... it ends is jut that perfect.
That is why I don't want TLOU 2 to be a sequel but a new complete adventure.
Aquamarine said:
Okay, I got word back from The NPD Group on what else I can and can't share precisely.
Here is what else I can share from this month. I'm really tired at the moment, so apologize for any possible minor errors.
By the way, if you crosspost any leak from this post on NeoGAF, please mention that the leaks came from me.
It's annoying me how people on NeoGAF won't even mention my name anymore...that's really stupid and I want to be at the very least recognized in some fashion.
Here are the new leaks I can post:
Quantum Break: Approx. 109K standalone
Star Fox Zero: Approx. 100K
Therefore:
Top 10 combined excluding bundles:
1. Dark Souls III (PS4, XBO) - 504k (~353K PS4, ~151K XBO)
2. Ratchet & Clank (PS4) 207.5k-237K range (highest selling Ratchet game)
3. MLB 16: The Show (PS4, PS3) - just under 185k
4. Tom Clancy's The Division (PS4, XBO, PC) - 175k including bundles
5. Grand Theft Auto V (PS4, XBO, 360, PS3, PC)
6. Minecraft (XBO, 360, PS4, PS3)
7. Quantum Break (XBO) - Approx. 109K standalone, somewhere below 150k including bundles
8. Call of Duty: Black Ops III (XBO, PS4, 360, PS3, PC) - 105k standalone, 262K including bundles (197K PS4 + PS3) (65K XBO + 360)
9. NBA 2K16 (PS4, XBO, 360, PS3) - 103k standalone
10. Star Fox Zero (Wii U) - Approx. 100K
Top 10 SKUs:
1. Dark Souls III (PS4) - ~353k
2. Ratchet & Clank (PS4) - 207.5K-237K range (highest selling Ratchet game)
?. Dark Souls III (XBO) - ~151k
?. MLB 16: The Show (PS4)
?. Quantum Break (XBO) - Approx. 109K
6. Star Fox Zero (Wii U) - Approx. 100K
?.
?.
9. Bravely Second: End Layer (3DS) - <100k, but not significantly
10. Pokkén Tournament (Wii U)
Hit the limit for # of consoles shared and # of 3rd-party games shared, so no precise Ratchet numbers, and no 3DS numbers.
3DS sucked this month anyway, really weak, no point in tracking handhelds, market is just about dead anyway...it's console or bust...and maybe somebody like Creamsugar or John Harker on NeoGAF will show up...you never know.
But I will say, Ratchet is not significantly above the >207.5K mark.
By this, I mean that Ratchet is below 250K....what the hell, I'll go closer...below...let's say...237K.So Ratchet and Clank is 207.5K - 237K. That's a close enough range.
Also, Nintendo in general was weak this month. Example: Twilight Princess HD was well below 125K, Fire Emblem: Fates well below 75K, Hyrule Warriors: Legends was well below 50K, etc. etc.
Up 23% thanks to catalog, but disappointing in new launches and recent launches.
Again, if you mention this on NeoGAF, say something like "From Aquamarine on the off-site source" or "From Aquamarine on VG Chartz"
VG Chartz was way off this month in terms of the actual retail software numbers.
The Division VG Chartz: 403K including bundles
The Division Real NPD POS numbers: 175K including bundles
Call of Duty: Black Ops III VG Chartz: 381K including bundles
Black Ops III Real NPD POS numbers: 262K including bundles
Star Fox Zero VG Chartz: 185K
Star Fox Zero Real NPD POS numbers: 100K
Quantum Break VG Chartz: 235K including bundles
Quantum Break Real NPD POS numbers: 109K-150K range including bundles
Bravely Default VG Chartz: 153K
Bravely Default Real NPD POS numbers: <100K
Those are some large margin misses this time around. In general, the software estimates made by VG Chartz way overshot the health of the USA market this month. Wonder what the precise methodology was to calculate these VG Chartz numbers and how much sampling was involved.
Boutros, I guess you can put that 75K number for 3DS in the OP because it's the only one we seem to have gotten.With all numbers in place, I overestimated PS4 by 20K, XB1 by 7K, Wii U by 7K, and 3DS by 15K. Not bad.
Also, I talked about the weak Nintendo catalog releases....
Hyrule Warriors: Legends well below 50K
Twilight Princess HD well below 125K
Fire Emblem Fates well below 75K
Pokemon Rumble World well below 40K
...
etc. Cut all of those numbers in half (or more) and you get a more realistic idea about their performance this month.
You can add that to the OP as well...this is a bad month for Nintendo's recent releases. Even Smash Bros. on a combined basis did better than some of them.
