Redfall launch trailer, reviews are here!

[Legend]

Xbox exclusives are pretty rare so we can't miss this opportunity!

86
81
74


I loved their last game Prey. Execution wasn't perfect but the concept was great. I also liked Deathloop from their sister studio.

Zero interest in this. I could not care less about the setting and the gameplay is not for me. Hopefully Microsoft encourages them to make an immersive sim after this.

[nnodley]

Man idk.  It looks pretty good and i'll likely play, but just don't know what the reviews will be.

i'll be optimistic and go :
90
85
78

[BananaKing]

I've seen very little of this. This is from the same dev as dishonored and prey 2 right?

Either way, I'll say

84
79
71

[kitler53]

i dunno.  i don't like participating in this but i think the game looks pretty mid.  not bad.  not great.   probably scores in the middle upper 80s.

[the-pi-guy]

85
79
74

[Legend]

i dunno.  i don't like participating in this but i think the game looks pretty mid.  not bad.  not great.   probably scores in the middle upper 80s.

I'll pull a metacritic and "extract" exact numbers from what you wrote.

89
87
80

I've seen very little of this. This is from the same dev as dishonored and prey 2 right?

Either way, I'll say

84
79
71

Yup, co-developed the first Dishonored and fully developed Prey (2017).

85
79
74

Both of you make me feel like I need to lower my prediction  

[Legend]

Launches tonight so I guess no pre-release reviews. I should have gone with a lower prediction  

[kitler53]

Launches tonight so I guess no pre-release reviews. I should have gone with a lower prediction  

[nnodley]

ahh yeah i guess i didn't realize the reviews aren't coming out before release. BIIIIIG RED FLAG

[Legend]

ACG review was live for a few minutes. Called it one of the worst games of 2023.

[Legend]

70 on opencritic with 10 reviews.
74 with 14 reviews
69 with 18 reviews. Oh no, if it stays in the 60s that'd be catastrophic.

[Legend]

66 with 23 reviews  

[the-pi-guy]

Worse than I originally expected.

Better than I expected after hearing "one of the worst games of the year"

[kitler53]

yeowch.  also haha!

[nnodley]

I mean it's not surprising but hey I was trying to be optimistic.  Let's see how starfield turns out as that's the only potential saving grace for Xbox this year at this point

I'll download just to try it