Forum's Favorite Game: pre-Round 1+Round 1

[the-pi-guy]

Spoiler for nominations:

<br>The Last of Us<br>Final Fantasy X<br>Uncharted 2<br>Super Mario RPG<br>Age of Empires II<br>Grand Theft Auto V<br>Mario Kart Wii<br>Pokemon Diamond<br>San Andreas<br>Super Mario Galaxy<br>God Of War 3<br>Heavy Rain<br>FEZ<br>Metal Gear Solid V<br>Mass Effect 2<br>Super Mario World<br>Final Fantasy VI<br>Final Fantasy VII<br>Devil May Cry 3<br>Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection<br>Braid<br>Flower <br>Riven <br>Rocket league<br>rachet and clank: CiT<br>Half-Life 2<br>Batman: Arkham City<br>Witcher 3<br>Gran Turismo<br>Bloodborne<br>Ocarina of Time<br>Metroid Prime<br>Majora&#39;s Mask<br>Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door<br>Chrono Trigger<br>Killzone 2<br>Vice City<br>God of War 2 <br>Red Dead Redemption<br>Super Mario 64<br>ICO<br>Shadow of the colossus<br>Atelier Rorona Plus<br>Final Fantasy IX<br>Lunar Silver star story &nbsp;<br>LOZ Ocarina of Time<br>Tex Murphy pandora directive<br>Astro Warrior<br>

I have pre round, just for the following reason: we have a lot of games, which is awesome.  But it also means that most users have likely
A.) Not played every game in the list.  
B.)  Not every user will take the time to give a score.  


Want to hear suggestions.  

I'm kinda of thinking the following idea is too much work.  But I'm sure a few users would be willing.

Spoiler for Hidden:

<br>Give every game a score.<br>1-you liked it.<br>0.5 - haven&#39;t played it, but think you would like it.<br>-0.5 haven&#39;t played it but think you wouldn&#39;t like it.<br>-1 - you disliked it.<br>

Probably just end up picking 5 or 10 games that you liked from the list.  

[Legend]

Do a voting round like you recommend to get some rankings, and then use that to set up a double elimination bracket. Ya!

[the-pi-guy]

Do a voting round like you recommend to get some rankings, and then use that to set up a double elimination bracket. Ya!

Do you as you wish!  

Otherwise, I could just take 10 games, have people vote on them, take the next 10 games, etc.  

[kitler53]

0.5 The Last of Us
-0.5 Final Fantasy X
1 Uncharted 2
-1 Super Mario RPG
0.5 Age of Empires II
-0.5 Grand Theft Auto V
-1 Mario Kart Wii
-1 Pokemon Diamond
-0.5 San Andreas
1 Super Mario Galaxy
1 God Of War 3
1 Heavy Rain
1 FEZ
0.5 Metal Gear Solid V
-0.5 Mass Effect 2
1 Super Mario World
-0.5 Final Fantasy VI
-0.5 Final Fantasy VII
-0.5 Devil May Cry 3
-0.5 Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
1 Braid
1 Flower
1 Riven
1 Rocket league
1 rachet and clank: CiT
0.5 Half-Life 2
-0.5 Batman: Arkham City
0.5 Witcher 3
-0.5 Gran Turismo
1 Bloodborne
1 Ocarina of Time
1 Metroid Prime
1 Majora's Mask
0.5 Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
0.5 Chrono Trigger
1 Killzone 2
-1 Vice City
1 God of War 2
-1 Red Dead Redemption
-1 Super Mario 64
1 ICO
1 Shadow of the colossus
-0.5 Atelier Rorona Plus
-0.5 Final Fantasy IX
? Lunar Silver star story  
1 LOZ Ocarina of Time
? Tex Murphy pandora directive
? Astro Warrior


i put question marks to a couple at the bottom.  never even heard of them so it's hard to even decide if i might like them.  to be honest,.. that's not a vote of confidence that they should be in the running of favorite game ever.

also,  rockstar games suck. 

[Mmm_fish_tacos]

0.5 The Last of Us
-0.5 Final Fantasy X
1 Uncharted 2
-1 Super Mario RPG
0.5 Age of Empires II
-0.5 Grand Theft Auto V
-1 Mario Kart Wii
-1 Pokemon Diamond
-0.5 San Andreas
1 Super Mario Galaxy
1 God Of War 3
1 Heavy Rain
1 FEZ
0.5 Metal Gear Solid V
-0.5 Mass Effect 2
1 Super Mario World
-0.5 Final Fantasy VI
-0.5 Final Fantasy VII
-0.5 Devil May Cry 3
-0.5 Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
1 Braid
1 Flower
1 Riven
1 Rocket league
1 rachet and clank: CiT
0.5 Half-Life 2
-0.5 Batman: Arkham City
0.5 Witcher 3
-0.5 Gran Turismo
1 Bloodborne
1 Ocarina of Time
1 Metroid Prime
1 Majora's Mask
0.5 Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
0.5 Chrono Trigger
1 Killzone 2
-1 Vice City
1 God of War 2
-1 Red Dead Redemption
-1 Super Mario 64
1 ICO
1 Shadow of the colossus
-0.5 Atelier Rorona Plus
-0.5 Final Fantasy IX
? Lunar Silver star story  
1 LOZ Ocarina of Time
? Tex Murphy pandora directive
? Astro Warrior


i put question marks to a couple at the bottom.  never even heard of them so it's hard to even decide if i might like them.  to be honest,.. that's not a vote of confidence that they should be in the running of favorite game ever.

also,  rockstar games suck.  

Lunar Silver star story is one of the best jRPG's of all time.

Tex Murphy games are point and click detective/puzzle games simular to myst but with superior story telling .

Asteroid warrior is pretty much the god father of shoot em ups/ bullet hell games that laid the foundation that all other where to follow.

[Rorono]

1 The Last of Us
1 Final Fantasy X
-1 Uncharted 2
-1 Super Mario RPG
1 Age of Empires II
-1 Grand Theft Auto V
-1 Mario Kart Wii
-0.5 Pokemon Diamond
-1 San Andreas
-1 Super Mario Galaxy
1 God Of War 3
-0.5 Heavy Rain
-1 FEZ
1 Metal Gear Solid V
-1 Mass Effect 2
-1 Super Mario World
0.5 Final Fantasy VI
-1 Final Fantasy VII
-1 Devil May Cry 3
0.5 Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
1 Braid
1 Flower
0.5 Riven
1 Rocket league
1 rachet and clank: CiT
-1 Half-Life 2
1 Batman: Arkham City
-1 Witcher 3
1 Gran Turismo
-0.5 Bloodborne
-1 Ocarina of Time
1 Metroid Prime
-1 Majora's Mask
-1 Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
-0.5 Chrono Trigger
-1 Killzone 2
-1 Vice City
1 God of War 2
-1 Red Dead Redemption
-1 Super Mario 64
1 ICO
1 Shadow of the colossus
1 Atelier Rorona Plus
0.5 Final Fantasy IX
0.5 Lunar Silver star story  
-1 LOZ Ocarina of Time
0.5 Tex Murphy pandora directive
0.5 Astro Warrior

[ethomaz]

Destiny or Gran Turismo.

[Legend]

1 The Last of Us
-.5 Final Fantasy X
1 Uncharted 2
.5 Super Mario RPG
1 Age of Empires II
1 Grand Theft Auto V
1 Mario Kart Wii
1 Pokemon Diamond
.5 San Andreas
1 Super Mario Galaxy
1 God Of War 3
1 Heavy Rain
1 FEZ
1 Metal Gear Solid V
1 Mass Effect 2
.5 Super Mario World
.5 Final Fantasy VI
.5 Final Fantasy VII
-.5 Devil May Cry 3
-.5 Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
.5 Braid
1 Flower
.5 Riven
1 Rocket league
1 rachet and clank: CiT
-.5 Half-Life 2
1 Batman: Arkham City
.5 Witcher 3
.5 Gran Turismo
.5 Bloodborne
.5 Ocarina of Time
1 Metroid Prime
.5 Majora's Mask
.5 Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
-.5 Chrono Trigger
.5 Killzone 2
-.5 Vice City
1 God of War 2
.5 Red Dead Redemption
1 Super Mario 64
1 ICO
1 Shadow of the colossus
-.5 Atelier Rorona Plus
-.5 Final Fantasy IX
-.5 Lunar Silver star story  
.5 LOZ Ocarina of Time
-.5 Tex Murphy pandora directive
-.5 Astro Warrior

[the-pi-guy]

1-The Last of Us
1-Final Fantasy X
1-Uncharted 2
1-Super Mario RPG
1-Age of Empires II
-1-Grand Theft Auto V
1-Mario Kart Wii
1-Pokemon Diamond
-0.5-San Andreas
1-Super Mario Galaxy
0.5-God Of War 3
0.5-Heavy Rain
0.5-FEZ
0.5-Metal Gear Solid V
0.5-Mass Effect 2
1-Super Mario World
0.5-Final Fantasy VI
0.5-Final Fantasy VII
-0.5-Devil May Cry 3
-0.5-Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
0.5-Braid
0.5-Flower
-0.5Riven
-0.5-Rocket league
0.5-rachet and clank: CiT
0.5-Half-Life 2
1-Batman: Arkham City
1-Witcher 3
0.5-Gran Turismo
1-Bloodborne
0.5-Ocarina of Time
0.5-Metroid Prime
0.5-Majora's Mask
0.5-Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
0.5-Chrono Trigger
0.5-Killzone 2
-0.5-Vice City
0.5-God of War 2
0.5-Red Dead Redemption
-1-Super Mario 64
0.5-ICO
0.5-Shadow of the colossus
0.5-Atelier Rorona Plus
0.5-Final Fantasy IX
0.5-Lunar Silver star story  
0.5-LOZ Ocarina of Time
-0.5-Tex Murphy pandora directive
-0.5-Astro Warrior

[the-pi-guy]

I'm going to be keeping this thread open for a while.
A lot of games, but fortunately, it's not as bad as it could be to have to run through everything.  It's not as much thinking as the nomination.


The reason for the 0.5 and -0.5 is because I think it's a little more fair.  If a lot of people haven't played a game, they will likely (undeservedly) just vote it out on the basis they haven't played it yet.  Think this gives less played (but still great) games a chance.  

[Xevross]

1 The Last of Us
0.5 Final Fantasy X
1 Uncharted 2
-0.5 Super Mario RPG
0.5 Age of Empires II
1 Grand Theft Auto V
1 Mario Kart Wii
1 Pokemon Diamond
1 San Andreas
1 Super Mario Galaxy
1 God Of War 3
-0.5 Heavy Rain
-1 FEZ
-0.5 Metal Gear Solid V
0.5 Mass Effect 2
0.5 Super Mario World
0.5 Final Fantasy VI
0.5 Final Fantasy VII
0.5 Devil May Cry 3
-0.5 Tekken 5/Dark Resurrection
-0.5 Braid
-0.5 Flower
? Riven
1 Rocket league
-0.5 rachet and clank: CiT
0.5 Half-Life 2
0.5 Batman: Arkham City
-1 Witcher 3
1 Gran Turismo
1 Bloodborne
-0.5 Ocarina of Time
-0.5 Metroid Prime
-0.5 Majora's Mask
-0.5 Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door
0.5 Chrono Trigger
1 Killzone 2
1 Vice City
0.5 God of War 2
0.5 Red Dead Redemption
-0.5 Super Mario 64
0.5 ICO
0.5 Shadow of the colossus
? Atelier Rorona Plus
0.5 Final Fantasy IX
? Lunar Silver star story  
? Tex Murphy pandora directive
? Astro Warrior

[Dr. Pezus]

Yeah keep it open over the weekend.

[the-pi-guy]

Yeah keep it open over the weekend.

Probably going to keep it open longer than that.  

After this round though, will make voting easier after the list has been trimmed.  

[the-pi-guy]

Is it okay if we get this stickied?  

[Legend]

Is it okay if we get this stickied?  

You are a mod, so feel free to sticky whatever you want.