-Are you sure you are still able to get free shipping if you buy a used game?
-Also, the disk itself should be absolutely fine. Shouldn't run into any issues whatsoever.
Only concern would be the GOTY part, code might be used already.
Yeah I just checked and I won't get free shipping if I buy used. I think I'll just buy it new I guess. It's 15$ new for Uncharted 2 and 20$ new for RDR, both GOTY editions.