Elden Ring does have plenty of things in the middle. There's even boss fights in the middle of nowhere. Random NPCs.
I personally think Skyrim's open world is good (even if it's not good for Kitler).
Elden Ring is like the antithesis of Skyrim's open world in a ton of different ways.
yeah but to me they aren't really designed to be "open world". they are always tethered to a location and if you step outside of the boundaries they de-aggro and reset. the design of the bosses are the same as if it was a very linear game with a "boss room". ...expect even worse because
1. the open world area never makes the boss fight more interesting. it's always a boring wide open field.
2. the bosses are all easy to cheese. you can just leave the aggro area to reset the boss. the bosses didn't even reset their life bar so the could easily be cheesed via a quick attack and run. aka boring and worse than the previous games.