From a purely mathematical point of view, how much more prestigious is a 95 vs a 94? 10/10 is the max score so it's a lot harder to get higher averages.Opencritic's chart is a good way to look at this. 94-96 is in the top 0.1% of games while 91-93 is top 0.4% of games. This means there's 3x more games in the 91-93 range than 94-96.
If you want to compare closer though, metacritic's all time chart has 55 games at 94, while only 20 at 95. So almost 3x more rare there too. That's actually the biggest jump as well.
92: 80 games
93: 57 games
94: 55 games
95: 21 games
96: 21 games
97: 15 games
98: 4 games
99: 1 game
94 --> 95 is quite a big difference it seems, using actual data.