I agree - it shouldnt be Game of the Year - it should be Story of the Year though
Btw I rated it 89 out of 100!
8/10 for me. Story was pretty good but the game itself was very boring to play. I love a good story in my single player games but I also want the game to be fun to play because to be honest that is what pushes me to continue playing a game to the finish. If a games not fun I just won't bother.
Far Cry 3 for instance had a meh story, but god dayum was it fun to play...Loved that game. Off topic but I was actually thinking about picking up a PS4 if they have a Far Cry 4 bundle here in Canada.