I'd probably score them about the same. But scores definitely don't tell the full picture.It's difficult because there are different types of games.
TL:DR The Last of Us is closer to perfection than Gow but I still like GoW more, how do scores reflect that?
Even ignoring different genres and just considering the same genre, different games are going for different things. Like two games might even be pretty similar, but one might be implementing more stealth systems or something. And it might be great for the one game, but it's not something you'd wish in the other game.
Does that mean one is a better game?