Monthly Metacritic Predictions! Jan Edition

[Legend]

So in these threads we'll predict metacritic scores for upcoming games. The twist though is that we predict scores for games months and months away. That way we can track predictions over time per game and see how media events affect our predictions.

Average for the month (so far, and capped at 100 lul)

Uncharted 4: 96
VizionEck: 84
The Order: 79, 83 after new trailer
Bloodborne: 90
Quantum Break: 80
Fable: 67
Screameride: 62
Halo 5: 85
Tomb Raider 86
Tearaway ps4: 88
Until Dawn: 72
Zelda U: 95
Star Fox: 76
Witcher: 86
Batman: 90
MGS5: 94
Evolve: 79
X: 84



My personal ones:

Uncharted 4: 98
VizionEck: 100
The Order: 74, 83 after new trailer
Bloodborne: 87
Quantum Break: 80
Fable: 62
Screameride: 69
Halo 5: 85
Tomb Raider 86
Tearaway ps4: 93
Until Dawn: 72
Zelda U: 96
Star Fox: 71
Witcher: 82
Batman: 86

EDT:
MGS5: 95
Evolve: 78
X: 84

Feel free to mention games I forgot.

[Rorono]

Uncharted 4: 95
VizionEck: 1000000
The Order: 80
Bloodborne: 88
Quantum Break: 76
Fable: 68
Screamride: honestly who cares
Halo 5: 86
Tomb Raider 83
Tearaway ps4: 87
Until Dawn: 72
Zelda U: 93
Star Fox: ?
Witcher: 85
Batman: 88

you forgot

MGS TPP: 95

[the-pi-guy]

Uncharted 4: 96
VizionEck: 93+8
The Order: 84
Bloodborne: 94
Quantum Break: 82
Fable: 65
Screameride: 59
Halo 5: 82
Tomb Raider 86
Tearaway ps4: 88
Until Dawn: 70
Zelda U: 96
Star Fox: 80
Witcher: 86
Batman: 92
MGS TPP: 94
Evolve: 82

[Legend]

Average so far

Uncharted 4: 96
VizionEck: 100
The Order: 79
Bloodborne: 90
Quantum Break: 79
Fable: 65
Screameride: 64
Halo 5: 84
Tomb Raider 85
Tearaway ps4: 89
Until Dawn: 71
Zelda U: 95
Star Fox: 76
Witcher: 84
Batman: 89
MGS5: 95


Also I forgot about X!: 84

[Dr. Pezus]

Uncharted 4: 93
VizionEck: 84
The Order: 77
Bloodborne: 90
Quantum Break: 83
Fable: 72
Screamride: 57
Halo 5: 86
Tomb Raider: 87
Tearaway ps4: 85
Until Dawn: 74
Zelda U: 95
Star Fox: 78
Witcher: 89
Batman: 93
MGS TPP: 93
Evolve: 76

[Legend]

Updated

Uncharted 4: 96
VizionEck: 84
The Order: 79
Bloodborne: 90
Quantum Break: 80
Fable: 67
Screameride: 62
Halo 5: 85
Tomb Raider 86
Tearaway ps4: 88
Until Dawn: 72
Zelda U: 95
Star Fox: 76
Witcher: 86
Batman: 90
MGS5: 94
Evolve: 79
X: 84

Also The order just released their new trailer today. At least personally that really bumped up my meta prediction for it.

I'm changing to an 83. Anyone else?

[Xbro]

Uncharted 4: 95
VizionEck: 92(You seem to have faith in it, so I'll trust you on this one)
The Order: 80
Bloodborne: 89
Quantum Break: 80
Fable: 65
Screameride: 58
Halo 5: 82
Tomb Raider: 84
Tearaway Unfolded: 90
Until Dawn: 70
Zelda U: 96(Seems to be around this that Console Zelda games get)
Star Fox: 85(Trust in Miyamoto)
Witcher: 87
Batman: 92
MGS5: 92
Evolve: 73
Xenoblade Chronicles X: 90(I think it will get around the same as the first game, which was I believe 92)

[Dr. Pezus]

I'm considering bumping up my The Order prediction but not sure

[Dr. Pezus]

How did you get the 84 average for VizionEck? Seems to only include my prediction lol

[Legend]

How did you get the 84 average for VizionEck? Seems to only include my prediction lol

At the time you were the only serious vote.

[the-pi-guy]

At the time you were the only serious vote.

My 93 was serious. 

[Legend]

My 93 was serious. 

I read it as a 101 lol.

[Xevross]

Uncharted 4: 97
VizionEck: 83
The Order: 84
Bloodborne: 92
Quantum Break: 83
Fable: 71
Screameride: 59
Halo 5: 87
Tomb Raider 83
Tearaway ps4: 92
Until Dawn: 75
Zelda U: 94
Star Fox: 72
Witcher: 88
Batman: 89
MGS5: 93
Evolve: 83
X: 89
Project Cars: 76
R&C Remake: 84
Fifa 16: 83
COD Blops 3: 89
Battlefield Hardline: 79

Added some more, because why not?

[Max King of the Wild]

I think vizioneck will get a 44. It will be slammed for being too grey and too derivative/generic

[Xevross]

I think vizioneck will get a 44. It will be slammed for being too grey and too derivative/generic

Not enough colours and looks exactly like so many other games out there, indeed.